10 Reasons Why The Auction Will End Broadcasting

10 Reasons Why A Spectrum Auction Will Kill BroadcastingToday’s Tech Spotlight on TVNewsCheck focused on the low power TV community and its concern for being squeezed out of a business following the pending spectrum auction and subsequent channel repack.

There was a quote in that piece from Paul Broyles, president of the International Broadcasting Network, which operates 10 low power stations in the state, that may have drawn some readers’ attention. “The International Broadcasting Network believes that going forward with the auction and repacking scheme will be chaotic, will result in the total destruction of the LPTV industry and will lead to the demise of the entire television broadcasting industry.”

It’s a bold statement.

I followed up with Broyles to make sure that’s what he really meant, and he replied to me with 10 reasons why he believes the auction and repack will lead to the end of the television broadcasting industry and gave me permission to publish them on Playout. Here they are:

1) The Commission will be flooded by permit applications as a result of the repack, and it will not have the ability to process them in an expeditious manner.

2) Manufacturers of broadcast transmission equipment will be unable to meet the sudden demand.  With manufacturers downsizing, moving overseas or going out of business, it’s already difficult to buy transmitting antennas, connectors and other products that the repack will require.

3) There will not be enough qualified tower crews to serve all the stations that will have to install new antennas.  Many tower crews have quit the business.

4) There will not be enough qualified RF engineers to install or retune all the transmitters that will be necessary as a result of the repack.  Older RF engineers are retiring at an alarming rate, and there are very few younger people who have any interest or desire to learn the trade.

5) Rebuilding or modifying a transmission facility usually requires approval from various federal, state and local agencies, and those approvals can be difficult to obtain.

6) For stations rebuilding near the Canadian or Mexican border, foreign approval will have to be obtained.  Obtaining Mexican approval can take years and often requires that illegal bribes be paid.

7) When a station is off the air for any extended period of time, as will be necessary during the repack, the station’s audience is lost.  It’s exceedingly hard to regain a lost audience.

8) When a station is off the air for twelve consecutive months, its license is automatically forfeited.

9) The repack will be so chaotic that viewers will give up on broadcast television and permanently switch to other sources for information and entertainment.

10) As for LPTV, lenders and investors will have no interest in supplying the funds necessary for rebuilding.

5 thoughts on “10 Reasons Why The Auction Will End Broadcasting

  1. James (Jimmy) Cieloha

    I hope that all in-market affiliated stations affiliated with ABC, CBS/CW, NBC, FOX/MYNET, and other broadcasting network be willing to allow all cable operators, Directv, Dish, and Aereo be allowed to carry out-of-market stations affiliated with the same network as the in-market station on the MSO and Aereo when the in-market station is off the air due to maintenance to adjust the equipment for the station to adjust the setting to transmit the equipment on another channel as a result of the spectrum auction and channel repacking.

    Reply
  2. newsbot

    If Aereo wins summary judgment, or if broadcaster-friendly parts of the 1992 Cable Act are repealed as Senator McCain is threatening, then no repacking will be necessary as broadcasters will simply take the money and run.

    Reply
  3. Pingback: 10 Reasons An Auction Will End Broadcasting | S...

  4. Steven Clark

    Everybody seems to miss the point of the auctions. From the creation of broadcast TV until the digital conversion each TV market had 2 to 20 channels available. When I was growing up in the Minneapolis-St. Paul market we had 5 channels, ABC, NBC, CBS, PBS, and an independent, plus a second PBS with a much weaker signal which only broadcast 7 hours a day Monday thru Friday. Cable came in and offered 50 to 100 channels and people flocked to Cable to get more choices. Since the digital conversion, I can now receive 47 channel(WUMN-LP Univision being the only analog left) with a 48th channel(Movies!) set to go on the air on next Monday. The eastern portion of the market can also get another channel from a Wisconsin PBS station. I’ve heard rumors of at least a dozen more channels which may be added in the next year. If anybody ever decided to advertise to the general public that they could get 40-50 channels for free, many would drop their expensive cable and satellite packages overnight and some of the more popular channels currently available only on cable and satellite would find their way to broadcast TV. The cable and satellite industry with the help of the FCC seem intent on destroying free over the air television before this can happen. When it does we only get whatever choices a few very large corporations and the government choose to allow, and freedom of choice in television will be dead.

    Reply
  5. Pingback: 10 Reasons An Auction Will End Broadcasting | U...

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>