Post-'Oprah' Newscasts: So Far, So Good

News, it turns out, is proving a worthy successor to The Oprah Winfrey Show.

Three of the seven top-25 market stations that launched news to replace the talker at 4 p.m. are holding their top positions in household ratings in the timeslot, and at least two more are leading their markets in key demos.

The stations that held their positions in households are the ABC O&Os in Philadelphia, San Francisco and Raleigh-Durham, N.C.

ABC’s WABC New York, Cox Media Group’s WSB Atlanta, Gannett’s KSDK St. Louis and Belo’s KGW Portland, Ore., all dropped a notch, but WSB and KGW say they are happy with how they are doing in the demos.

Not surprising, none has been able to match Oprah's audience.

Bill Carroll, EVP and director of programming at Katz Television group, says he sees the newscasts as generally successful, but it will be several months before their true value can be measured.

“We have a snap shot of where things are at this particular moment, but you ultimately have to drill down and look at the demographics and what impact — positive, negative or neutral — they have on the newscasts that follow," he says.

Here’s a market-by-market look at how the newscasts are doing based on household ratings for the first two weeks of October ending last Wednesday (Oct. 12):

New York: (DMA 1):  With a 2.3 rating/7 share, WABC dropped to second behind Judge Judy on WCBS.

Philadelphia (DMA 4): WPVI, ABC's long dominant station, held on to its No. 1 ranking with a 4.0/10, competing against Dr. Phil on CBS O&O KYW and news on NBC O&O WCAU.

San Francisco (DMA 6): KGO’s newscast with a 1.8/6 kept the ABC O&O No. 1, just ahead of Judge Judy on CBS O&O KPIX, Dr. Oz on Cox’s Fox affiliate KTVU and Dr. Phil on KRON, Young Broadcasting’s MNT station.

Atlanta (DMA 8): WSB’s newscast dropped to No. 2 with a 3.1/8, trailing Dr. Oz on Fox O&O WAGA.

St. Louis (DMA 21): KSDK ‘s half-hour newscast had a tough time competing against The Young and the Restless on KMOV, Belo’s CBS affiliate, and Judge Judy on Local TV’s Fox affiliate KTVI. It slipped from No. 2 to No. 3 with 4.0/10 share.

Portland, Ore. (DMA 22): The newscast KGW launched Sept. 12 earned a 2.1/6, but fell from first to second behind news on KATU, Fisher’s ABC affiliate.

Raleigh-Durham (DMA 24): ABC's WTVD newscast, which launched its 4 p.m. newscast in May, ranked No. 2 in the time period with a 3.4/8, but so did Oprah, so it maintained its position.

ABC also replaced Oprah with news at its KFSN Fresno, Calif., and so now is airing news at 4 p.m. across the eight-station group.

“Our 4 p.m. newscasts in New York, Philadelphia, San Francisco, Raleigh-Durham and Fresno are off to tremendous starts, providing our viewers with even more quality reporting and insight than they expect from our local news teams,” said Rebecca Campbell, president of the ABC Owned Television Stations Group, in a statement prepared for this story (Campbell declined to be interviewed).

Broadcasters at WSB and KGW also say they are pleased with the way things are going so far.

Steve Riley, WSB’s creative services director, says the newscast is performing well among coveted demographics, placing No. 1 in the time period with adults 25-54 during October to date. In addition, the news audience is more evenly divided between men and women, with women making up 46% of the newscast’s audience compared to 76% of Oprah’s.

“We did our homework,” Riley says. The station added reporters, photographers and writers along with its news hour, he says. “We are bringing in that much more content.”

In Portland, where KGW created the third 4 p.m. news in the market, the station’s Richard Jacobs says he, too, is getting the viewers he wants. “We launched the show on Sept. 12 and so far we are leading the market in the key demographic, women 25-54,” he says.

Gannett declined to discuss its newscast on KSDK, which also launched Sept. 12, yet, saying it was too early to talk.

While stations that lost Oprah may have been able to hold their positions with news or other syndicated shows, they have not been able to hang on to all of Oprah’s audience. In fact, they have come up far short.

In Atlanta, for example, Oprah earned a 6.5/15 during the first two weeks of October last year. It earned a 5.2/13 in Philadelphia. In San Francisco, Oprah had a 4/13.

But, as Jerry Gumbert, president and CEO of AR&D, the media strategy firm, says, even a moderately rated newscast could be considered successful — at least financially — because they are so much less expensive than Oprah, the most expensive daytime talk show ever.